✨✨✨✨

A Little Magic in Every Loaf

Good Witch Baking Co is a home bakery rooted in Youngstown, OH — built on a love for sourdough, warm kitchens, and the belief that really good bread changes your whole day.

Hi, I'm Mikayla Moore

It started the way most good things do — out of necessity and a little obsession. After falling down a sourdough rabbit hole right before my 30th birthday… what began as a single loaf on the counter turned into a full-blown baking practice, then a community, then Good Witch Baking Co.

The name felt right from the start. There's something a little witchy about fermentation — the patience it takes, the way a starter comes alive, the transformation that happens in the oven. I lean into that magic.

Today I bake out of my home kitchen in Youngstown every week, taking pre-orders on Mondays with pickups that Sunday. Everything is made in small batches, by hand, with ingredients I actually care about and taste test to make sure they meet my own standards.

Ready to Try Some Magic?

Pre-orders open every Monday. Place yours and I'll have something fresh waiting for you Sunday.

Good Witch Baking Co

A little magic in each bite💖

✨⭐🌟✨⭐

© 2026 Good Witch Baking Co. All rights reserved. Made with love & a pinch of magic.